News and Information

Tips for selling management rights
Tips for selling management rights
by John Mahoney 29th March, 2017

Tips for selling management rights

As I have said in previous Resort News articles, and at the risk of stating what to many might seem obvious, the most important piece of advice I can give potential sellers of a management rights business is to prepare for your sale well in advance.

 

Before you actually list the business for sale, there is so much that can be done to make the sale as smooth as possible. So how should you prepare for a sale?

 

Letting appointments

 

First, check your letting appointments. POA forms 6 are automatically assignable but not PAMD forms 20a. If you are relying on these, to be assignable they will need to have the assignment section ticked and initialled or you will have to obtain the consent of all owners to an assignment to the buyer. It is also an offence for you, in the case of a letting appointment without an assignment clause, to assign that appointment without the owner’s consent

.

Almost without exception, buyers are insisting that all appointments be properly assignable and assigned at settlement or the purchase price be reduced for non-compliant appointments. We have seen purchase prices heavily discounted and some contracts terminated because the sellers did not want to, or were not able to, assign appointments.

 

If your appointments are not assignable, you should consider new appointments (particularly if the existing ones are a few years old as there have been many changes that should be incorporated) under POA.

 

Management rights agreements

 

Next, check your body corporate agreements.

 

Locate copies of all of the relevant agreements with the body corporate – copies of the caretaking and letting agreements, deeds of assignment, deeds of variation and the like. If my firm has acted for you, you would have all of these documents in the indexed binder we give our clients after settlement of their purchase

 

Get the real estate agent you have selected to scan electronically and/or take photocopies of these to give to prospective buyers. You should also give your solicitor copies of these documents for two reasons. First, your solicitor can check that everything is in order - for example, that options have been properly exercised.

 

Secondly, if the buyer’s solicitor or financier raises questions about the agreements during the course of the transaction, your solicitor will be able to deal with the matter quickly and efficiently.

 

Term of agreements

 

The term remaining on your agreements is critical. Unless you have long-term agreements with your body corporate, you should be thinking about how the term of your agreements will impact on a future sale as early as the time you buy.

You must also consider that most (if not all) buyers looking at a complex in the standard module will these days want close to the full 10 years to run on agreements when they purchase. With complexes in the accommodation module, most buyers will be looking for at least 15 years but some buyers and their financiers want even longer, depending of course on the amount being borrowed.

 

If you buy with 10 years or so to run on your agreements, you will invariably will have to secure, add another option before you sell.

 

The transfer fee rules will not penalise you just because you sell within two years of getting a new agreement or adding a new option. It is only if you sell within one to two years of becoming manager that the transfer fee applies in which case the body corporate must impose a transfer fee of three percent or two percent of the business sale price.

 

Adding a new option to an existing agreement is technically prescriptive. Apart from getting a new agreement, this is the only way that the term can safely be extended. Because of these technical requirements, many lawyers and body corporate managers have failed in their attempts to extend the term.

 

Because of our involvement in the legislative changes (in fact we designed the prescribed statutory form that must accompany the motion to add the new option), we have been called upon on a number of occasions to remedy ineffective additional options ruled invalid by the body corporate commissioner’s office.

 

Termination clause in agreements

 

Much has been written about the Gallery Vie QCAT decision and the changes that financiers want made to the termination provisions in management rights agreements to deal with the problem created by that decision.

 

If you have not already done so you should have your lawyer check your agreements to make sure they are Gallery Vie compliant. If they are not you really should take steps to amend the agreements to deal with the issue.

 

The changes can be done in a simple and straight forward way but do require an AGM or an EGM. Most managers are dealing with the matter at the same time as they are topping up their agreements.

 

Financial figures

 

You will need up-to-date financial figures. Take the time and spend the money to get up to date figures for sale purposes from your accountant. So many sellers rely upon outdated financial figures or on figures that are not really prepared for sale purposes.

 

I have seen a number of sellers grossly underestimate their net profit and find that the buyer’s accountant has verified a net profit well in excess of that shown in the contract. With multipliers of around five and above, a difference of only $5000 will cost you more than $25,000 – enough to cover a fair component of the agent’s commission.

 

Make sure you get the most up-to-date figure you can. You would expect these to show a higher figure than figures a month or two older but if they don’t, you can at least decide what it is you are going to rely upon and include them in the contract.

 

Make sure your body corporate salary has been updated to take into account the latest CPI increases or any market review that might be permitted under your agreement.

 

Get expert help

 

Above all, use the experts.

 

You might think that you don’t need an accountant or a specialist accountant to put together your net profit figures. As any honest accountant will tell you, it is a very specialised area. As a general rule, figures prepared according to normal accounting standards will show a net profit lower than the way in which it is calculated for sale contract purposes. Only a specialist accountant will be able to produce accurate figures.

 

You might be tempted to use a local or suburban lawyer because they offer a cheaper rate. Although as a general rule there are fewer legal issues when you are selling than when you are buying, I have seen so many sellers get themselves into trouble because they have tried to save money by using a lawyer who does not specialise in the area.

 

You need someone who understands management rights to be able to deal with any issues raised by the buyer or the buyer’s solicitors – so often we are able to salvage a sale transaction because of our expertise and ability to convince other solicitors of our view of the legal position.

 

Perceived savings on commission might encourage you to market your business yourself rather than use an agent and sometimes you might succeed. But there are downsides. A good agent will help guide a buyer through the purchase process and often keep together a sale that might otherwise fall apart. I have seen that happen on more than one occasion.

 

A good agent will also pre-qualify a buyer to ensure that your time is not wasted by people who will not get finance approval.

 

On the other hand, if you are able to find a buyer yourself then an experienced lawyer will be able to handle contract preparation and negotiation.

 

John Mahoney

Founding Partner

Mahoneys Lawyers

Tags:

Share: